Annual Evaluation Report (Inside).pdf 1 10/21/18 7:50 PM Annual Evaluation Report 2017 OPERATIONS EVALUATION DEPARTMENT Annual Evaluation Report (Inside).pdf 2 10/21/18 7:50 PM Annual Evaluation Report (Inside).pdf 3 10/21/18 7:50 PM TABLE OF CONTENTS TABLE OF CONTENTS ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS i ii ACRONYMS AND ABBREVIATIONS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 01 CHAPTER - I : INTRODUCTION 2 2 4 4 28 CHAPTER - III : DEVELOPMENT RESULTS 41 CHAPTER - V: RECOMMENDATIONS AND MANAGEMENT RESPONSE AND ACTION A.Background and Objectives B.Evaluation Planning, Methodology and Criteria C.Enabling and Dissemination Activities D.Organization of the Report 29 A.Agriculture and Rural Development 30 B.Water and Sanitation Sector 30 C.Transport Sector 31 D.Energy Sector 32 E.Education Sector 33 F.Health Sector 34 G.Finance Sector 35 H.Industry and Mining Sector 42 42 A.Synthesis of Recommendations B.Implementation of Recommendations iii iv 05 CHAPTER - II : PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS 36 6 11 23 A.Ordinary Capital Resources (OCR) Projects B.Higher Level Evaluations C.Other Evaluations 37 LESSONS Learned 38 LESSONS Derived CHAPTER - IV: LESSONS LEARNED 43 ANNEX ANNEX 44 46 48 51 53 54 A.Main indicators for projects evaluated in 2017 B. Evaluated projects with major changes in scope in 2017 C.Evaluated projects with implementation delays in 2017 D.Cost variations in evaluated projects in 2017 E.Criteria based rating for evaluations in 2017 F.Recommendations from 2017 evaluations i Annual Evaluation Report (Inside).pdf 4 10/21/18 7:50 PM TABLE OF CONTENTS LIST OF TABLES LIST OF FIGURES ii 7 Table 1: Other Evaluations Undertaken during 2017G 8 Table 2: Average Success Rating per Sector 6 Figure 1: Number of OCR Project Evaluations during 1432H-1438H/2017G 6 Figure 2: Regional Coverage of Project Evaluations in 2017G 6 Figure 3: Distribution of Projects Evaluated by Mode of Finance 6 Figure 4: Sector Distribution of Project Evaluations in 2017G 7 Figure 5: Overall Performance Ratings of Randomly Selected Evaluated OCR Projects in 2017 7 Figure 6: Success Rate of Evaluated Projects across Regions 7 Figure 7: Sector Performance Ratings of Evaluated OCR Projects in 2017G 8 Figure 8: Distribution of 2017G “Relevance” Assessment 9 Figure 9: Distribution of “Effectiveness” Assessment in 2017G 9 Figure 10: Implementation Delays of Evaluated Projects in 2017G 10 Figure 11: Cost Variation in Evaluated Projects in 2017G 10 Figure 12: Distribution of “Efficiency” Assessment in 2017G 10 Figure 13: Distribution of “Sustainability” Assessment for Evaluated OCR Projects during 2017G 11 Figure 14: Comparison of Distribution of the Ratings of PCRs and PCR-Ens 11 Figure 15: IDBG Finance for Tunisia from Inception - US$ Millions (1977-2016) 12 Figure 16: IDBG Pillar-Based Approvals Vs Disbursement (2013 - 2016) 15 Figure 17: IDBG Yearly Approval Trend for Niger (1977-2015) in US$ million 19 Figure 18: IDBG Approvals under the MCPS Kazakhstan and PFA (2011-2017) 23 Figure 19: Number of Loans Received by Economic Activity Annual Evaluation Report (Inside).pdf 5 10/21/18 7:50 PM ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS This report was prepared by a team led by Mohammed Jalaludeen Issahaq and comprised of Javeed Ahsan, Adamou Sanda Mayaki, Amin Yusuf Abdullahi, Mustapha Jammeh, Ahmed Warfa, and Nabeel Kasmani.

ANNUAL EVALUATION REPORT GROUP OPERATIONS EVALUATION DEPARTMENT ANNUAL EVALUATION REPORT FOR THE YEAR 2016G 2016 G ISLAMIC DEVELOPMENT BANK GROUP I GOED TABLE OF C O N T E N TS TABLE OF CONTENTSI ACKNOWLEDGEMENTSII ACRONYMS AND ABBREVIATIONSIII EXECUTIVE SUMMARYIV 1 5 21 1. A.

Amended and Restated Master Trust Deed in respect of the U.S.$25,000,000,000 Trust Certificate Issuance Programme Dated 30 September 2024 IDB Trust Services Limited (Trustee) IsDB Trust Services No.2 SARL (Trustee) The Islamic Development Bank (IsDB or Guarantor) The Law Debenture Trust Corporation p.l.c. (Delegate) Dentons & Co.

ISSUE NO.20 | JUMADA 2 - 1446H - DECEMBER 2024 LIFE ON LAND: PATHWAYS TO A SUSTAINABLE FUTURE IsDB stands ready to work alongside its member countries, international organizations, and civil society to accelerate efforts towards drought resilience and sustainable land management. Dr.